William Katz:  Urgent Agenda

HOME      ABOUT     CONTACT 

 

 

 

 

WHAT WE SEE – AT 8:52 A.M. ET:  The Republican debate was Wednesday night.  This is what we are seeing in response.  (Click on "see more."): 

There have been very few useful polls to come out of the debate.  Some are online polls, which are voluntary and thus subject to manipulation by campaigns urging followers to get online and vote.  Others have been too narrow.  The most interesting poll, by Gravis, surveyed Republican voters who watched the debate. 

Washington, D.C., September 17, 2015 - One America News Network, “OAN”, a credible source for 24/7 national and international news, announces its national post-debate poll taken immediately after Wednesday night’s GOP Debate at the Ronald Reagan Library. Carly Fiorina jumps to first place at 22 percent, tied with Donald Trump. OAN’s previous national poll, conducted on September 3-4, showed the former HP top executive in seventh place with 2.7%. Marco Rubio lands in the third spot with 15 percent. The U.S. Senator from Florida ranked third in OAN’s early September poll with 12 percent, a three point gain for Rubio. Rounding out the top five are Dr. Ben Carson at 12 percent followed by Ted Cruz and Jeb Bush tied at 6 percent. Bush drops nearly half his early September support of 11.4 percent to a post-debate 6 percent.

Obviously, this is an immediate reaction to the debate, but it demonstrates the truth of what most pundits said – that Fiorina won the debate and is actively challenging Trump, but that Rubio also made impressive gains.

We'll be looking for other polls.

Also, what we saw yesterday was a remarkable number of stories about Carly Fiorina's record as CEO of Hewlett-Packard.  The stories were less than favorable.  It was not only Carly's statistical record that was reviewed, but her management style and personal approach.  She did not come off well.  However, it should be pointed out that 1) any new CEO coming in to save a company is going to leave many unhappy people, especially those who are fired or sidetracked, and 2) Fiorina's tenure at HP ended ten years ago. 

If Fiorina winds up on the ticket she will have to defend her record, but she does so very articulately.  Whether her defense can be convincing may be another story.  One thing is clear:  In terms of debating and being quick on her feet, she is the best Republican candidate.  In terms of articulating detailed policy positions, I'd put Rubio at the top.

It is very early.  A year from today we might look back on our observations and laugh, but I don't think so.  Two debates give us a pretty good picture of how candidates present themselves.

The biggest loser in the debates so far, and it's surprising, is Scott Walker, a man who's used to rough politics and who's always come out ahead.  But he's not translated his success as governor of Wisconsin into a convincing national run.  That might change, but Walker is running out of time to make his case. 

On Donald Trump:  The general feeling I've seen is that he didn't do himself any good in the debate, but didn't make any huge mistakes either, except for being Trump-like.  Voters like him because he presumably "tells it like it is."  Maybe so, but there's a growing belief that he also has to "tell us what he'd do."  The missing policies are starting to show.

September 18, 2015